The Farm Says It Posted the Warning Signs. Does That End a Florida Injury Claim?

At a Florida pumpkin patch, harvest festival, U-pick farm, petting zoo, or other farm attraction, a warning sign can do more than tell visitors to be careful. Under Florida’s agritourism statutes, properly posted notice can be part of the operator’s legal path to immunity from certain injury claims.

A new Miami-Dade appellate decision shows why the details matter. In Collado Laguna v. The Berry Farm, LLC, No. 3D25-1982 (Fla. 3d DCA Oct. 28, 2026), the Third District Court of Appeal reversed summary judgment for a farm after concluding that a jury could reasonably dispute whether the required statutory warning signs were actually posted when the injury occurred.

The decision does not hold that every injury at a farm attraction creates liability. It does not even decide whether the playground injury in that case resulted from an “inherent risk” of agritourism. Its narrower point is important enough on its own: when a business invokes statutory agritourism immunity, it must be able to prove the statutory conditions for that protection.

At a farm attraction, a sign can be a legal switch

Florida’s agritourism framework appears in sections 570.85 through 570.89, Florida Statutes. Under the current section 570.88, an agritourism operator, its employees, and the underlying landowner can receive significant protection from claims for injuries resulting from the inherent risks of agritourism activities. But the statute expressly ties that protection to the notice required by section 570.89 being posted as required.

The current section 570.89 is unusually specific. The operator must post and maintain the statutory notice in a clearly visible location at the entrance to the agritourism location and at the site of the agritourism activity. The lettering must meet a minimum size and contrast requirement, and the statute prescribes the substance of the warning. The same section says that failure to comply prevents the operator from invoking the statutory immunity.

That makes the signage issue different from an ordinary argument about whether a visitor saw a generic “use at your own risk” placard. The question can be whether the operator satisfied a statutory prerequisite to immunity.

What happened at The Berry Farm

Amanda Collado visited The Berry Farm in Miami with her three-year-old son during its 2021 Harvest Festival. According to the Third District’s opinion, she fractured her ankle after her feet hit the ground while she was using a slide in a children’s playground area.

She later sued for negligence, alleging failures involving the condition and operation of the premises and the slide. The farm raised Florida’s agritourism statute as an affirmative defense and moved for summary judgment.

The farm’s evidence included an affidavit from its owner stating that statutory warning signs were posted at the entrance and near the playground. It also relied on photographs of example signs. The trial court accepted that evidence and entered judgment for the farm on the theory that the agritourism statute barred the claim.

The Third District reversed.

Why the photographs did not end the dispute

The appellate court focused on the evidence tied to the actual date of the accident.

Collado testified that she did not see the statutory warning signs and went further than simply saying she could not remember them. According to the opinion, she testified that the signs shown to her in defense exhibits were not present on the day of the incident. The farm’s photographic evidence also had timing problems: two of the example photographs were dated June 2022, months after the October 2021 accident, while another image did not clearly establish where the sign was located.

Those competing facts mattered because the farm carried the burden of proving the affirmative defense on which it sought summary judgment. The Third District concluded that credibility and the weight of the competing evidence belonged to a jury rather than the judge at summary judgment.

The lesson reaches beyond agritourism. A photograph can show that a sign existed when the photograph was taken. It does not necessarily prove that the same sign was in the same place, with the same wording and visibility, on the date of an earlier injury. That is why contemporaneous evidence can be so important in a Florida personal injury claim.

The Third District did not decide whether the slide injury was an “inherent risk”

This is one of the most important limits of the opinion.

Florida’s current section 570.86 defines an agritourism activity broadly as certain agricultural-related activities connected with a bona fide farm, ranch, livestock operation, or working forest that allow the public to participate for recreational, entertainment, or educational purposes. The statute’s definition of “inherent risks” includes dangers integral to agritourism, such as certain conditions of land, vegetation, water, animals, and ordinary dangers associated with structures or equipment used in farming and ranching.

In Collado Laguna, the injured plaintiff separately argued that her slide injury did not result from an inherent risk of agritourism. The Third District expressly declined to decide that issue because the disputed signage evidence was enough to reverse the summary judgment.

So the opinion should not be read to mean that a children’s slide is automatically an inherent risk of agritourism—or that it is automatically outside the statute. That question remains fact-dependent and was not resolved in the decision.

Agritourism immunity is narrower than “the accident happened on a farm”

The location alone is not the legal test.

Before statutory immunity can end an injury claim, several questions may matter: Was the defendant an agritourism operator or protected landowner? Was the visitor participating in an agritourism activity as the statute defines that term? Did the injury result exclusively from an inherent risk covered by the statute? Were the required notices posted and maintained as required?

Section 570.88 also contains express exceptions. The statutory limitation does not protect conduct amounting to gross negligence or willful or wanton disregard for participant safety when that conduct causes the injury, and it does not protect an intentional injury.

That is very different from saying that buying a ticket to a farm festival waives every claim arising on the property. The applicable facts and statutory elements still have to be established.

Why the scene should be documented before it changes

Collado Laguna is a useful example of how quickly the most important evidence can become historical.

A visitor may return months later and find new signs, a remodeled entrance, a relocated activity, different fencing, or a changed layout. A farm may replace weathered signs or add new ones after an incident. Online ticketing language and website notices can change. Seasonal attractions may disappear entirely after the event ends.

When it can be done safely, photographs taken on the date of an incident can preserve the entrance, the activity area, the exact location and visibility of posted warnings, the surrounding crowd flow, lighting, fencing, equipment, and condition of the ground. Tickets, wristbands, receipts, online confirmations, waivers, maps, and screenshots of the operator’s website or social-media pages may also establish what information was actually presented to visitors at the relevant time.

The Third District specifically considered social-media screenshots and photographs as part of the summary-judgment record. The point is not that an Instagram image automatically proves what was or was not on a property. The point is that evidence tied closely to the incident date can become important when later photographs tell a different story.

What happens if the agritourism defense does not apply?

Defeating an immunity defense does not prove negligence. It simply means the claim is not disposed of on that defense.

The injured person still has to prove the elements of the applicable negligence theory, including duty, breach, causation, and damages. Depending on how the injury occurred, the case may involve the physical condition of the property, the operation of an attraction, employee conduct, warnings, supervision, equipment, or some combination of those issues.

Those concepts overlap with ordinary Florida premises-liability law, but they should not be mechanically treated as a standard grocery-store slip-and-fall. Tucker Law’s Florida slip-and-fall practice page explains the broader premises framework, while our discussion of Florida theme-park injury claims illustrates how the visitor’s legal status and the scope of an invitation can change the duty analysis in a very different recreational setting.

The practical takeaway from Collado Laguna

A farm attraction’s warning sign may be important, but the legal analysis does not end with the statement that “there was a sign.”

For statutory agritourism immunity, the location, wording, visibility, timing, and proof of the required notice can matter. So can the nature of the activity and whether the injury truly resulted from an inherent risk covered by the statute. The Third District’s October 28, 2026 opinion reinforces that courts cannot resolve genuine credibility disputes in favor of a defendant simply because the defendant has an affidavit saying the statutory conditions were met.

If you were injured at a Florida farm attraction, festival, recreational property, or other business premises, preserving the scene and identifying the legal framework early can make a substantial difference. Tucker Law’s Personal Injury Information Center provides additional guidance on evidence, damages, insurance, and litigation. To discuss a specific Florida injury, contact Tucker Law.

This article discusses the Third District’s October 28, 2026 opinion as issued. The opinion states that it is not final until disposition of any timely motion for rehearing. The court applied the 2021 versions of the agritourism statutes; the key signage and immunity provisions discussed above remain in the current 2026 statutes. This article provides general information, not legal advice.

Contact Us

I hereby expressly consent to receive communications from Tucker Law including calls, texts, emails, and/or prerecorded messages.